Rating foreign stock brokers 2025

World brokers — best online stock brokers, comparison of tariffs, trading services, pros and cons, tax. Rating foreign stock brokers

Rating stock brokers

The best world brokers for clients from Europe, America, Asia and other continents.

Rating
Advantages
The widest range of services for traders and investors in the EU
The World's Most Popular American Discount Broker
The widest selection of ETFs, profitable options on US exchanges and structured bonds
For professional and high-frequency traders. Deposit from 10,000 EUR
Premium European broker for wealthy clients

The list includes only time-tested brokers with licenses from national regulatory government organizations.

Table of contents

Pros and cons foreign brokers account

Advantages and disadvantages of opening a foreign brokerage account for clients of different countries and tax jurisdictions.

Pros

  • Brokerage account is insured, the amount depends on the broker's jurisdiction
  • Diversification - your assets are located outside your country
  • Wide opportunities for optimizing taxable profits through offshore schemes
  • There are brokers that provide deposits, withdrawals and trading in cryptocurrencies, which minimizes commissions, transaction and tax costs
  • You get access to more exchanges and investment instruments
  • High liquidity of markets and a larger number of trading participants
  • Direct and fast access to foreign exchanges and their instruments (depends on the broker's jurisdiction)
  • Laws and terms of service are stable and transparent

Cons

  • For minimize commissions, it is more profitable to deposit $1,000 or more into accounts and make monthly transactions
  • Foreign brokers are not tax agents in country of registration client`s, so it is necessary to submit reports to the tax authorities independently
  • Using financial and investment services requires experience, knowledge and language, otherwise you will have to extra pay for consulting
  • To obtain a profit much higher than the average market yield, clientы needs to take a high risk
  • National financial regulators and authorities are trying to create conditions so that clients' money remains within the countries where the clients are registered, which leads to restrictions on the movement of capital between jurisdictions

Questions and Answers

Services, rates, commissions, pros and cons

Broker Pros Cons Fees Custody, accounting, withdrawal
Securities Currencies Derivatives
Just2Trade
5/5

For whom?

For a universal type of investor in any foreign assets. Has had Cyprus jurisdiction since 2006. Part of the international Lime Financial group and licensed in the EU, UK, USA.

Site

+ Private client accounts are insured by the Cyprus Investor Compensation Fund up to €20,000 per client

+ Possibility of input, output and trading of both national currencies of countries and crypto assets on a brokerage account (commission for deposit = 0%, for withdraw = 0.5%)

+ J2T bank card for instant payment of purchases using funds from a brokerage account

+ The holding has branches in Europe, USA, China, India, Malaysia, Russia and CIS

+ Multilingual support 24/7 and a good understanding of the specifics of clients in different regions

+ Bonuses up to $2000 for margin trading for new clients

+ Счёт MT5 Global without service fees with with Metatrader 5 trading terminal

+ Direct Access to USA Exchanges via sub broker Lime Financial (member FINRA&SIPC, NFA )

+ Terminals for professional traders for algorithmic and high-frequency trading (for accounts from $5000)

+ Quick invest in American IPO from $1000

+ A wide range of solutions and investment products (auto-following, structured products, robo-advisor, cryptocurrencies, cfd contracts, options solutions)

+ Best Robo advisor service on the market for building a portfolio based on your personal targets and risks

+ Service Copytrading ( "J2T Copy" ) for deals of public accounts of the best traders

+ You can create an unlimited number of brokers sub-accounts for your strategies

- There are fees for dividends (from 2-3%), for inactivity: if there were no transactions, then $50 per quarter. For a voice order: $5

- Commission from $1.5 per order, except for trader Special Tariffs

- The minimum amount for participation in the IPO is $1,000
Commissions 4% for participation and 1.75% for early exit during the lock-up period

- There is a subscription fee for trading terminals: Sterling = 150$/month, Lightspeed = 250$/month

- Client must calculate and pay taxes independently at the place of tax residency

- Risks of some service strategies copytrading for deals of public traders' accounts

- In accordance with the requirements of European regulators, replenishment and withdrawal of funds from brokerage accounts in cryptocurrency is limited, but it is possible to replenish a brokerage account from a bank card through a special crypto exchanger of the broker J2TX.com

Investors:

USA Exchanges: 0,006$ per shares (1 order = 1,5$) Europe: 0,14% for deal,
Asia: 0,3% for deal (6$ for order) Bonds = 0.128% for deal

Custody transaction securities in J2T from another broker:
10% from the value of securities, but not less than 200 Euro

Traders:

from $0.0035 and below per share depending on turnover
+ 3% of profit per month. (min. account = $5000) + payment for trading terminals

Special tariff:

Margin loan 0.025% per day (9.5% per annum)

Traders:

Currencies:
Minimal lot: from 0,01
brokerage commission: 2$ per lot (min. deal 1000$)
Spreads: from 0 to 0.3
For example: USDEUR Swap 12% per long position

Bonus for new clients: money on account for margin trade up to $2000


Digital currencies :

Fixed commission for any pairs = 0,35%,
Fixed fee for transaction volume in any tokens = 0,1%,

Margin loan for popular currencies up to 1:5
Commission for overnight: 0,06%

Withdrawal of funds from the exchange: 0,5% from the withdrawal amount

Investors:

Up to 500 futures contracts = 1,5$/unit

Traders:

from 500 to 1000 contracts = 1.25$/unit
* At Lightspeed and Sterling terminals : up to 500 option contracts = 2,15$/unit, more 500 = 1,5$/unit On terminal MetaTrader 5 : up to 500 option contracts = $5/unit

Custody free, if total fees are less than $5, then fee = $5/month

withdrawal:

It is possible to make purchases via virtual J2T bank card

1. Bank cards: free if return to the same card. Otherwise: 2.5%, minimum $1

2. To bank accounts = 0.4%, not less than 40 USD/EUR (waiting time 2-3 days)

3. Fast withdrawal via digital currencies = 0.5% in USDС/BTC/ETH, but not less than 15USDС / 0.0005 BTC / 0.02ETH

4. Many payment services and electronic money: PayPal, Neteller, Skrill and other

Deposits and withdrawals in cryptocurrency are available through a special crypto exchange broker J2TX.com

All payments system look this: сonditions

Interactive Brokers
5/5

For whom?

For clients who need an American broker jurisdiction, the lowest commissions among American brokers, low lending rates, brokerage account insurance up to $500,000

Site
Interactive BrokersPros

+ The best commission among US brokers

+ Free withdrawal of funds once a month

+ The broker is not accountable to the Central Bank of the Russian Federation

+ Access to all major world exchanges and a huge number of trading and investment instruments

+ Multifunctional trading terminal on WEB and mobile platforms

+ In fact, the only full-fledged US broker for clients from the Russian Federation

+ The account is insured by American regulators and insurers

Interactive BrokersCons

- Risks of blocking accounts due to requirements of American regulators

- Minimum deposit 2000$

- Minimum recommended deposit for competitive rates from 10000 $

- Difficult to understand trading terminal interface

- It is difficult for beginners to calculate all additional fees

- Submitting tax reports independently

- Restrictions for citizens of those countries that are subject to EU and US sanctions

Interactive BrokersSecurities

Investors:

$0.005 per share (but not less than $1 per order) + US exchange, regulatory and clearing fees

Traders:

$0.0035 per share (min. order: $0.35)

Special tariff:

ETF for investors without commission
* for traders + US fees: Distribution:0.0005$
Clearing:0.0002$
Transit:0.00056$
FINRA:0.000119$
Margin loan ~5.830% (Benchmark rate + 1.5%)
Interactive BrokersCurrency

Traders:

0.2 basis points * transaction amount (1 bp = 0.0001)
2$ за поручение
Interactive BrokersDerivatives

Investors:

$0.85 or EUR 0.65 per contract on US exchanges

Traders:

$0.85 or EUR 0.65 per contract on US exchanges
* + US exchange, clearing and regulatory fees
Interactive BrokersCustody: Service is free if assets are more than $10,000

withdrawal:

Once a month free, then $10 withdrawal or equivalent in account currency
Freedom24
4/5

For whom?

Global brokerage holding whose shares are traded on the Nasdaq exchange. Access to trading terminals via the Tradernet and CQG platforms

Site
Freedom24Pros

+ Client accounts are insured in the Cyprus Investor Compensation Fund up to 20 000 euros

+ Bonuses when opening an account: gift stock exchange shares up to $800 for residents or EU residence permits when replenishing an account from 5,000 EUR

+ Access to 15 largest stock exchanges in America, Europe and Asia from one account

+ Clients are sent daily investment ideas (more like research) on specific Western companies with deep analytics, targets, timeframes, risks.

+ About 500,000 clients worldwide

+ Development in Fintech through its own IT company: its own trading terminal and a fully functional mobile application

+ Has 98 offices in 13 countries: USA, Germany, Cyprus, Austria, Bulgaria, Greece, Spain, Netherland, Poland, France, Italy, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, 2500+ employees

+ High-quality and prompt multilingual support 24/7

Freedom24Cons

- No access to currency trading

- They do not provide access to popular investment products: copytrading, robo-advising, structured products, pre-IPO, crypto and digital assets

- Initially, broker is focused on the American market

- Has a brokerage license in Cyprus

- High margin loan rate: 15-18% per annum in usd and euro

- High fees for inter-depository transfers of securities, for example, to another broker

Freedom24Securities

Investors:

US, European, Asian exchanges: 0,02 $/eur for equities (2$ for order)

Traders:

0,012$ for equities (1,2$ for order) + 0,5% from each transaction
OTC deals: 0.12% from one transaction and 30 euros for custody
Margin loans: 0.049315% per day
Freedom24Currency

Investors:

Does not provide access to trading on the currency markets
Freedom24Derivatives

Traders:

Futures on non-US exchanges: 1.5 USD/EUR per contract
Options on US exchanges: $0.65 per contract
Freedom24Custody: There is no subscription fee for account maintenance

withdrawal:

7 USD / EUR for 1 order to withdraw funds to a card or bank account

Depositing account:
0% by bank transfer
2% by bank card

EXANTE
4/5

For whom?

For professional traders who need fast access to any global exchange at any time through a European jurisdiction

Site
EXANTEPros

+ Transparent tariff line

+ Low tariffs for European exchanges

+ Technology of fast order submission

+ Fast access to any world exchanges

+ For professional traders

EXANTECons

- Minimum deposit from 10,000 EP

- Margin loan only with 100% overage

- Is a sub-broker

- No insurance of funds

EXANTESecurities

Traders:

US Exchanges: $0.02 per share
Europe: 0.05% of the transaction,
Asia: 0.08% of the transaction + additional commissions
Bonds = 9 basis points
Fee for online quotes from $10/month.

Margin loan

issued only with 100% cash collateral
Short positions on shares = 12% per annum
EXANTECurrency

Traders:

average spread of currency pair = 0.5
+ commission for cash conversion = 0.25% for major currency pairs Favorable rate on short = 12% and lower,
Individual % rate for overnight position
EXANTEDerivatives

Traders:

USA: $1.5 per contract (ICE = $2.5)
Europe: 1.5 euros per contract
Asia: $2.5 per contract
EXANTECustody: No fees
Bond custody = 0.3% per annum There is an inactivity fee = 50 EUR / month (if the balance is < 5000 EUR and there have been no transactions for 6 months)

withdrawal:

30 USD or EUR for any withdrawal
ETORO
4/5

For whom?

International broker for investors from Europe and the USA and those who want to connect to the accounts of other traders and copy the deals of the best.

Site
ETOROPros

+ Trading US stocks, including fractional parts

+ Ability to connect to the automatic following of the best managers' trades
CopyTrader

+ Для Управляющих активами более 500К $ комиссии = 2% от активов

+ For Asset Managers over $500K, commission = 2% of assets Terminal and social network with traders' chat available via Web browser

+ Convenient application and exchange for trading digital currencies in the form of CFDs

ETOROCons

- For clients not from the US, this is essentially a dealer, you do not acquire assets in ownership, you bet on the future rise/fall in asset prices, while when buying real shares, eToro acts as a sub-broker with full regulation

- For non-EU, US, GB citizens, customer onboarding will be on a Cypriot company

- Quotes from price providers are not always market-based, there are slippages

- Support in English 24/5, during business hours on weekdays

ETOROSecurities

Traders:

spread between purchase and sale prices of shares and ETFs = 0.09%

Special tariff:

0% commissions on trades with US corporate stocks
* !!! Purchase of real shares (not contracts) is available for clients of Western Europe and Australia !!!

Margin loan

rollover of position to buy = 6.4% + 1 month LIBOR rate (~1.55%), (for example, rollover of $1000 per day = $0.22)
rollover of position to sell = 2.9% + 1 month LIBOR (for example, rollover of $1000 per day = $0.22)
ETOROCurrency

Traders:

Spread on Currency pairs depending on the pair, for example: USDEUR = 3 pips Transfer of a position overnight (rollover) chording then the formula:
(quantity * price) * (1% / 365) + (unit of measurement * market rate for tomorrow)
ETORODerivatives

Traders:

Spreads depending on the contract, for example:
Oil = 5 pips
Gold = 45 pips
S&P500 = 75pips

Carrying a position over night using the formula:
(quantity * price) * (1% / 365) + (units of measurement * market rate for tomorrow)
ETOROCustody: withdrawal is free, because basically these are not real assets, but contracts

withdrawal:

All withdrawals = $5 Club Platinum and above clients receive free withdrawals

Which broker to choose? Conclusions from the comparison table

We recommend TOP-3 foreign brokers

Favorable commissions, reliability, a wide range of markets and instruments, quality of support from these brokers:

These brokers allow you to have assets of less than $10,000 on your account without additional fees. Brokers, which have American and Cypriot jurisdiction respectively, have demonstrated their reliability, customer focus and service convenience over a long period of time.

InteractiveBrokers

Interactive Brokers - largest American discount broker, the most popular broker among non-American clients in the USA

The lowest commissions among trading on American exchanges. The advantage of tariffs for traders (more than 3 transactions within 5 days) starts from assets in the amount of more than $ 25,000. The broker does not accept payments in rubles. There is a risk of blocking the accounts of Russian citizens. The broker strictly complies with all sanctions and regulatory restrictions.

After tens of millions of dollars in fines from American regulators, Interactive Brokers began cleaning up client accounts. In case of suspicious, non-standard activity on accounts, they begin blocking accounts or suspending withdrawals until they receive evidence of the origin of the client's money!

Just2Trade

Just2Trade - formerly an American broker, bought by structures of a financial group popular in Eastern Europe, subsequently transferred to Cypriot jurisdiction and is a partner of a large American brokerage company.

One of the best offshore brokers for non-Euro-American investors and traders. Provides the most comprehensive set of investment solutions: from foreign exchanges to digital currencies. Provides reliable access infrastructure through American upstream brokers of the Lime financial group (member of FINRA & SIPC, NFA).

The investment product capabilities of this broker are the best among European offshore brokers: many auto-following strategies (J2T Copy), simple and clear robo-advising (J2T Robo-advisor), favorable conditions for structured products with capital protection (J2T IIP), professional trading terminals (Metatrader, Lightspeed, Sterling, CQG), regular offers to buy shares of companies on the pre-IPO, IPO and OTC market, favorable commissions on the foreign exchange market, access to trading cryptocurrencies, and other investment services.

Trading in cryptocurrencies is carried out within the personal account or the broker's trading terminal through its own exchange J2TX.

Freedom24 (ex.Freedom Finance Europe)

Freedom Finance Europe brokerage holding listed on the American Nasdaq stock exchange. They have about 100 offices in cities in 12 countries: the USA, Germany, Cyprus, Russia, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, Spain, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Greece and Ukraine. One of the fastest growing brokers in Cyprus with American shareholders.

The broker's key services are: direct access to 15 of the world's largest exchanges in the USA, Europe, and Asia via the Tradernet and CQG terminals. Also offer favorable terms on structured bonds, options on US exchanges, and the widest range of targeted ETFs to suit any needs. Interesting services include daily company research with the publication of investment ideas, as well as lessons from the broker's interactive academy.

European stock brokers

European brokers for clients from Asia, USA, Middle East, CIS and other

List of European Brokers

  • Just2Trade — the best European broker for trading on international markets with a full list of investment instruments
  • Freedom24 — Best for selecting target ETFs and structured bonds
  • Exante — for professional trading on European exchanges (from 10,000 EUR)
  • EToro — social network of copytrading users and access to international markets
  • CapTrader — german universal broker for retail investors
  • Saxo Bank — one of the oldest Danish universal broker and bank in Europe

Market regulation

The European jurisdiction of a broker implies the presence of a license from a financial regulator. The regulator supervises the activities of brokers.

European regulators:

  • CySEC — Cyprus (Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission)
  • ESMA — United Europe (European Securities and Markets Authority)
  • BaFIN — Federal Financial Supervisory Authority of Germany
  • FCA — United Kingdom (Financial Conduct Authority)
  • other countries

Insurance

Clients' accounts are insured in specialized compensation funds. Depending on the country of registration, the insured amount is from 20,000 to 100,000 euros.

How is the brokerage market structured in Europe?

The European broker market can be divided into 4 types of brokers:

  1. Brokers-banks
  2. Brokers of each country - working for the domestic market
  3. Brokers of world brokerage holdings
  4. Offshore brokers

Which brokers provide services to clients from non-European countries?

The most suitable for opening a brokerage account are offshore brokers. These are brokers with licenses:

  • Cyprus
  • Malta
  • Saint Vincent and the Grenadines

Why offshore brokers?

The fact is that the requirements of international financial regulators lead to the fact that the countries of the Eurasian continent have become jurisdictions with increased supervisory requirements for European brokers. Of course, clients with large capitals can open accounts in the oldest European banks such as Raiffeisen, Credit Swiss, Saxo Bank and others, but whether such investors will be able to withdraw money back without additional control, anti-money laundering procedures and confirmation of the origin of capital is unknown.

Therefore, a compromise option is European brokers from countries with preferential tax regimes (offshore brokers of Europe). Such brokers have to really compete (fight) for the client with large international financial holdings in strict supervision conditions and budgets incomparable with classic banks.

Conclusions and features

Offshore brokerage structures have been operating in Cyprus for many years. There have been no cases of intentional failure to fulfill obligations due to the fault of brokers.

Sanction requirements and increased supervision have to some extent complicated interactions with investors from non-European countries.

For example, Exante, popular with traders and previously specializing in the IPO Freedom Finance Europe, as well as the broker with the social network of social trading Etoro, have suspended remote account opening for residents of Russia, some CIS countries, the Middle East and Asia.

A universal European broker where you can open an account without restrictions on the country of residence is Just2Trade (part of the American Lime Financial). This broker continues to work efficiently with any category of clients.

Reviews, comparison, pros and cons of European brokers are presented in the table with services and commissions

American brokers

Best US stock brokers for foreign investors

Advantages of American Brokers

Brokers licensed by US regulators have $500,000 in insurance coverage for client accounts.

American brokerage firms are historically the largest and most technologically advanced companies providing access to financial markets. Unfortunately, not many of the largest American brokerage firms open accounts for non-American citizens.

List of top US brokers

  • RobinHood — trading via a streamlined mobile app with Zero comission
  • Interactive brokers — the most popular American broker for international clients
  • Charles Schwab — broker one of the investment gurus
  • ETrade — Morgan Stanley bank broker
  • Fidelity — universal TOP broker and asset manager
  • Firstrade — for commission-free options trading
  • Merrill Edge — Bank of America
  • Webull — high interest on uninvested cash
  • JP Morgan Chase — TOP 3 among American investment banks
  • SOGOTRADE — options broker for American clients
  • TD Ameritrade — one of the best trading platforms
  • Tradestation — British subsidiary of Interactive Brokers, which accepts wealthy clients
  • Ally — syndicate Ally+Tradeking family

Best American Broker

Unfortunately, in accordance with the requirements of US legislation, not all American brokers are ready to work with third-party clients with capital of less than $100,000. The most popular among non-US investors and traders is Interactive Brokers (IB). To compare IB with other brokers, you can use table with services and commissions of foreign brokers

This discount broker has the best foreign market commissions among US brokers, but the real benefit starts at account sizes of $25,000 and above.

Risks of investing through Interactive Brokers

Recent trends in the regulation of the American brokerage services market in relation to non-US residents have shown that in case of suspicious and non-standard activity on accounts, IB begins to suspend operations up to blocking and forced closure of accounts.

It should be noted that foreign subsidiaries of offshore brokers and brokers from Europe have shown in recent years that they can create effective and convenient investment platforms operating at acceptable commissions and transparent conditions. They are no worse, and in some places even better, than their competitors from the USA.

Brokers for trading in Asian markets

Hong Kong Stock Exchange Brokers for Clients from Russia, Asia, CIS, Europe, Africa, Middle East

Asian Brokers and access then Asian Exchanges

An ordinary individual from third countries will not be able to remotely open a brokerage account with a Hong Kong or Chinese broker. And even if you come to Hong Kong or mainland China, the likelihood of opening a brokerage account with a local broker is also not high. To access Asian exchanges, it is easier to use brokerage accounts of American, European or Russian brokers that have agreements with brokers and exchanges in Asia. We will discuss the access process from the standpoint of possible risks.

Legal Risks of Owning Shares in Chinese Corporations

Under Hinse love, persons who enter are not citizens of Maine China or Hong Kong are not able to acquire owner-management rights in Hinse shares.

All these companies: Alibaba, Xiaomi, Tencent, JD.com, Geely and many other Chinese multinationals, in order to circumvent the Chinese government's restrictions on foreign investment and optimize the taxation of investors, issue shares to foreign investors on behalf of special VIEs (Variable interest entities). The Hong Kong Stock Exchange is an offshore market, VIE structures are usually registered in offshore zones in the Cayman Islands.

What are investors actually buying on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange?

In these special companies, internal agreements stipulate the interaction of Chinese structures, but not guarantees and obligations to foreign investors. An analogue can be found in SPV (Special purpose vehicle/entity) - corporate currency bonds of national companies in each country registered in European jurisdictions. This is done to attract foreign capital to national companies according to the rules of European legislation.

But China has made the property rights structure of its companies much more rigid. In essence, foreign investors can one day, at the will of the Chinese government, cease to be owners of shares in Chinese corporations. Of course, it is unlikely that this will happen, because China is very interested in having foreign capital in its companies, but such a risk exists.

In principle, this is a global trend: protectionism and protecting one's markets from the influence of foreign capital. After the stories with European depositories blocking Russian currency bonds, one can either accept infrastructure risks or stop investing in foreign jurisdictions altogether.

Infrastructure risks and access costs of Hong Kong-listed stocks

If you agree to accept the "indirect rights to income" format in Chinese corporations, then the following options are available:

1. Buy Hong Kong shares on your country's domestic exchange or broker (if the exchange offers this option)

To buy Chinese stocks, you can open an account with a broker in your country with access to the Hong Kong Stock Exchange or the local exchange where the Chinese company is listed.

With this option, you need to take into account that this is not direct access to companies and commissions increase. If this is a broker, then you need to clarify in which depository the securities of Chinese companies you bought will be stored and through which sub-broker your broker carries out transactions. Most likely, your broker carries out transactions on the Hong Kong exchange and takes higher commissions from you, increases the risk of counterparty chains and provides low speed access to trading.

2. Direct access to the Hong Kong Stock Exchange

American and European brokers offer direct (sub-broker access) to the Hong Kong stock exchange. With this option, the investor eliminates the risk of the counterparty of the national exchange and the local broker, but the risk of the sub-broker and the legal risk of owning Chinese shares on the Hong Kong stock exchange remain. At the same time, the broker's commission increases and the minimum order size increases depending on the lot of the stock being traded (minimum $ 1000).

For example, for a Cypriot broker Just2Trade.

Purchase of $1,000 worth of Xiaomi shares:
Brokerage commission: 0.3% of the transaction, but not less than 6 USD. Exchange fees for purchasing shares: 0.1377%, minimum 1 HKD. Clearing fees: 0.092%, minimum 40 HKD (the same will be for selling.)
In this case, the clearing commission is included in the brokerage. The minimum purchase lot, for example for shares, will be 100 shares.
As a result, the commission will be on average: 0.6 - 0.8% of the transaction. In the case of dividends, the commission for payment on the European and Asian markets is 3% of the volume of incoming dividends, minimum 3 USD for each issuer.

For other European and American brokers, the commission for direct access to the Hong Kong exchange will be slightly higher, in the region of 1-1.5% of the transaction.

Currency risks

Almost always, conversion from one national currency to another is technically carried out through the US dollar. Why? Because the most developed system of correspondent bank accounts is in US dollars. The yen, yuan and even the euro cannot boast such an account system.
Settlements in national currencies are a long process and not always profitable for the parties to the transaction. Any attempts to create alternative settlements to the dollar system are a confrontation with the US or it is simply not profitable because in order to buy goods, you will need to buy dollars anyway.

The currency of settlements on the Hong Kong exchange is the Hong Kong dollar (HKD).

  • The Hong Kong dollar is pegged to the US dollar
  • 7.75–7.85 HKD per $1 — this rate has been maintained by the local Central Bank since 1983 with the help of currency interventions
  • The Hong Kong dollar rate may currently differ from the world rate, but the difference will decrease as trading volumes increase

It is known that Hong Kong is very sensitive to its status as a global financial center, therefore it complies with all legislative and regulatory requirements of the EU and the USA. But this also means that difficulties with dollar circulation in the world may also affect the Hong Kong dollar circulation.

Conclusion: If you want to invest in Asian and particularly Chinese corporations for the long term, then taking into account the legislative peculiarities of registering property rights, the risks and costs exceed the potential profitability. This is due to the legal structure of the issuers of shares, the currency risk of the Hong Kong dollar and the long chain of intermediaries.

On the other hand, given the rapid growth and development of the Asian region, the deep interpenetration of the interests of global investors and the development of communication channels, Asia is perhaps the most promising alternative diversified market among developing ones.

The question of choosing an operator for access to Asian exchanges can be reduced to the following logic:

If you are a citizen of a country outside the European Union or the United States and you do not have large amounts, for the purposes of short-term and medium-term investments, it is advisable to invest through the infrastructure of national brokers or European offshore brokers.

If your citizenship is in the European Union or the USA and you are a medium-term or long-term investor with capital over $10,000, then American or European brokers with direct access to the Hong Kong or other Asian stock exchanges are suitable for you.

List of brokers for access to the Hong Kong stock exchange

  • Core Pacific - Yamaichi — opening an account in person at the office
  • Interactive Brokers — remotely, but recommended assets from $10,000
  • Saxo Bank — remotely, but recommended assets from $10,000
  • Just2Trade — the best offshore european broker
  • Freedom Finance Europe — the best European broker for savings and savings accounts in dollars and euros
  • Finam — Russian broker with direct access to HKSE remotely opening accounts for all CIS citizens

Reviews, comparison, pros and cons of brokers for access to the Hong Kong stock exchange are presented in table with services and commissions

Which brokers remotely open accounts for citizens of the Russia, CIS and the ex. USSR?

Best european brokers for countries CIS

Unfortunately, for popular European and American brokers, clients with passports of former republics that were part of the Soviet Union attract at least increased attention from the point of view of procedures for monitoring the origin of funds, combating money laundering and compliance with sanctions. We are talking about passports of citizens of Russia, Ukraine, Kazakhstan, Belarus, Uzbekistan, Moldova, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan, Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan and Georgia. The Baltic countries (Latvia, Lithuania, Estonia), which joined the European Union, inspire greater confidence in large brokerage companies.

CIS citizens with large capitals are a desirable client for any broker - but only at the entrance (the stage of depositing money into the account). But when withdrawing this money, in accordance with the directives of the US and EU financial regulators, brokers can request documents confirming the origin of these funds or otherwise create ambiguous barriers. Another issue is that ordinary citizens from the CIS countries who have no relation to state or sanction lists are of little interest to the controlling units of foreign brokers. In this regard, brokers with licenses from offshore jurisdictions (Cyprus, Malta, Belize, Estonia, the Grenadines, the Virgin Islands, the Marshall Islands and other jurisdictions with a special tax regime) are much more loyal.

Of course, the question of the reliability of offshore brokers arises here. There is only one answer - at present, even the largest American brokers do not provide a 100% guarantee of the reliability of funds. It is important to pay attention to the broker's work experience, which supervisory authority regulates it, reputation, reviews and many other parameters.

Broker Deposit, withdrawal Trading platforms Trading tools Investment products Broker services
Just2Trade
5/5

For a universal type of investor in any foreign assets. Has had Cyprus jurisdiction since 2006. Part of the international Lime Financial group and licensed in the EU, UK, USA.

Site

Client from Europe

USD, EUR, BTC, USDC, ETH, LTC

Client from USA

no

Client from Asia

EUR, USD, RUB, BTC, USDC, ETH, LTC

East and CIS

EUR, USD (+ Finam Bank), RUB (no sanction bank), BTC, USDC, ETH, LTC, XRP

Trade terminals Metatrader 4 and 5

CQG Trader 

For professional traders on international markets there are special trading terminals: Sterling trader=150$/mounth, Lightspeed trader=250$/mounth. (for accounts from $5000)

+ integration with a large number of third-party trade applications

Currency Stocks Bonds Futures Commodities Funds/ETF Asset management Individual Retirement Accounts (IRA) Copytrading and signals Investment strategies Structured products Demo-accounts Marging On average 9.2% per annum. (For Forex: Standard leverage starts at 20% for liquid stocks, 5% for currencies and 1:3 leverage for cryptocurrencies) Voice Account Management from $5 to $8 per order Trading robots Preparation of tax returns
Freedom Finance Europe
4/5

Global brokerage holding whose shares are traded on the Nasdaq exchange. Access to trading terminals via the Tradernet and CQG platforms

Site
Deposit, Withdraw

Client from Europe

EUR, USD

Client from USA

no

Client from Asia

EUR

East and CIS

Russians and CIS citizens open an account with a Kazakh affiliated broker Freedom Finance Global

Trade platforms

Trading terminal of internal development "Tradernet"

Terminal CQG and its modules

Instruments for trading Currency Stocks Bonds Futures Commodities Funds/ETF Investment products Asset management Individual Retirement Accounts (IRA) Copytrading and signals Investment strategies Structured products Broker services Demo-accounts Marging Voice Account Management Trading robots Preparation of tax returns
Interactive Brokers
5/5

For clients who need an American broker jurisdiction, the lowest commissions among American brokers, low lending rates, brokerage account insurance up to $500,000

Site
Deposit, Withdraw

Client from Europe

USD, EUR

Client from USA

USD, EUR

Client from Asia

CNY, USD, EUR

East and CIS

USD, EUR, CNY
Trade platforms

IB Trader Workstation (TWS)

IBKR Platform

 

Instruments for trading Currency Stocks Bonds Futures Commodities Funds/ETF Investment products Asset management Individual Retirement Accounts (IRA) Copytrading and signals Investment strategies Structured products Broker services Demo-accounts Marging Voice Account Management Trading robots Preparation of tax returns only from US

There are a small number of brokers in the world licensed by European and American financial regulators - the founders (shareholders) of which are citizens of the former USSR. In practice, oddly enough, it is these brokers who know, are able and work well with clients from the CIS. It so happened that after the collapse of the USSR, native Russian speakers dispersed all over the world and began to create successful businesses, including in investments. For example, the founder of the trading company XTX Markets, Alex Gerko, who was born in Russia, became the largest taxpayer in Great Britain. Or the founder of the Russian Finam and the Cypriot Just2Trade - Viktor Remsha created the American investment holding Lime Financial, which successfully competes in the American brokerage market. Or the founder of the investment holding Freedom Finance Timur Turlov, who created the only Russian-Kazakh broker that managed to pass the listing on the American exchange - Nasdaq.

The largest foreign brokers created by people from the USSR: Just2Trade, Freedom 24, Exante – have licenses from the Cyprus Securities Commission and representative offices in all major countries. These international investment and brokerage companies have been working with CIS citizens for a long time, know the specifics and offer reliable and high-quality service, proven by many years of practice.

For citizens of Belarus, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Moldova, Turkmenistan, Tajikistan - the most technologically advanced Russian broker Finam has created a separate service - remote opening of a brokerage account in 24 hours using passport data.

Why do you need an account with a foreign broker?

A stock market broker is an intermediary between an investor and the Stock Exchange. On foreign stock exchanges, this principle is the same as in your country.

Therefore, first of all, an investor needs to decide whether he really needs a foreign broker?

  • — If you just need to buy stocks of large international corporations like Apple, Facebook or McDonald`s, then it is enough to open an account with any broker in your country with access to one of the American exchanges or if such securities have been listed on the national exchange of your country, then buy them on it
  • — If foreign jurisdiction, account insurance, high liquidity, a large number of investment products and financial instruments are important to you, then you can consider the conditions of foreign brokers

Deposit and withdrawal of funds from a foreign broker

A feature of the process of transferring funds to a foreign account of a foreign broker is the close attention of any bank in accordance with the requirements of the Government of your country. As a rule, most banks have limits on amounts above which the Bank through which you transfer funds may require supporting documents. (In many European countries, this amount is more than $ 10,000 per transaction). There is a possibility that your bank or payment system, when transferring funds to a foreign broker, may ask for: a copy of the agreement with the foreign broker in which you have an account. You can easily send an electronic version of the agreement received in the broker's personal account, after which the Bank will transfer funds for a commission established by the tariffs of your bank, and possibly without commissions.

Let's note the features:

For brokers located in jurisdictions with preferential tax regimes (offshore brokers), there is an opportunity to transfer money in digital currencies and even cryptocurrencies.

For large American or European brokers, stricter KYC (Know Your Client) and AML (Anti-Money Laundering) rules apply. Funds are accepted using bank details. And then, depending on the amount, you may be asked to provide documents confirming the legal origin of your funds. For example, a contract of sale of an apartment or a certificate from the place of work on average earnings.

Withdrawing money from a brokerage account:

European and American brokers, as a rule, require that funds be withdrawn to the bank account from which the money was deposited into the brokerage account. (Thus, almost all brokers will refuse you the withdrawal of funds to third-party accounts or to other accounts in other banks). At the same time, the process of withdrawing funds may also be accompanied by control by the control and “anti-money laundering” internal departments of brokers or banks.

On the other hand, there are foreign brokers registered in countries with preferential tax regimes. For example, offshore brokers in Cyprus are more loyal to control over the withdrawal of money. Of course, it is unlikely that you will be able to withdraw amounts over 100,000 dollars per hour, but in general, even with supervisory checks, the withdrawal time is from several hours to two days.

Minimum fees for withdrawals from foreign accounts range from 0 to $30. For large amounts, fees can reach several hundred dollars.

Again, we repeat that brokers registered in jurisdictions with preferential taxation allow you to quickly withdraw funds through digital currencies, with a total withdrawal fee of about 2%, anonymously, decentralized within the time set by the brokerage regulations. The transactions themselves in digital currencies have long been safe and take minutes, depending on the blockchain (network) of such a currency.

Note that well-known and large brokers may request additional documents when withdrawing a sum of money of several tens of thousands of dollars at a time. For example, well-known American and European brokers from the USA (Interactive brokers), Denmark (Saxobank), Great Britain (TradeStation) have mandatory "anti-money laundering" AML control procedures and if the payment raises questions, it may be stopped until additional proceedings are appointed.

Conclusion: Of course, citizens leading a lawful way of life and paying all taxes have no reason to worry. But the modern world is changing so quickly that even very wealthy and law-abiding citizens can, simply through carelessness or due to a technical failure or other reasons beyond their control, become the target of inspections by authorities and regulators of the countries where foreign brokers are registered. This does not include political risks between countries or simply attempts at fraudulent actions by third parties. Therefore, the process of choosing a broker and conducting transactions must be approached responsibly and diversified.

How to choose foreign broker?

Foreign stock broker. How to choose?

The key parameters when choosing a broker are its:

  • Reliability — will the broker go bankrupt or will the regulator revoke its license?
  • Services and products — what investment products does the broker offer for all categories of investors and traders
  • Commission size - what are the rates, how much commission will you pay for transactions, margin loans, storage, terminals, access to markets
  • User support — the quality of the broker's consulting and technical support, including in the client's native language
  • Personal account and account management — how to quickly and conveniently deposit and withdraw funds, receive account reports
  • Trading software — convenience, practicality and variety of broker trading terminals for traders' tasks, mobile versions, additional modules for algorithmic, high-frequency and robotic trading

Criteria for choosing a foreign broker

1. Availability of licenses from regulators and the country of registration of a foreign broker. Each country has its own supervisory and regulatory body that monitors compliance with investors' rights. For example, in the USA, brokers are supervised by: SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission). In Cyprus: CySec (Cyprus SEC), in Britain: FCA (Financial Services Authority), in Germany: Bafin (Federal Financial Supervisory Authority) and others.

2. Insurance of clients' funds (for example, in the USA all accounts and securities are insured by the regulator for up to $500,000, in Cyprus up to 20,000 EUR, but it is true that in the event of the collapse of large brokers and banks in the Russian Federation the state came to the rescue)

3. Methods of depositing and withdrawing money from the account, their speed of crediting and withdrawal. The more banks from different countries, methods of interaction, payment systems, digital currencies, the better and indicates that infrastructure organizations are ready to work with the broker, which have even more regulatory oversight than the brokers themselves.

4. Clear regulations and commission rates (a document similar to General Terms and Conditions for the Provision of Investment Services is available, which sets out the terms, rules and procedures for the broker's work in the main investment areas. Rates and commissions are transparent, simple and accessible without any non-obvious features)

5. Multilingual support, its availability and competence. All brokers have customer support, for example, European languages and Russian are available to almost all brokers, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week and not all of them are online. It is difficult to assess the level of competence of support until you become a client, but calling / writing a letter to support in your language and simply inquiring about the services will already give you some information about the quality of the broker's specialists.

6. Interface, format and speed of managing funds on your account. You can try to deposit several hundred dollars and check how quickly they will arrive and be displayed in the client's personal account. Then conduct test purchase and sale transactions for the instruments of interest, receive a brokerage report and then withdraw funds. This will give you an understanding of the speed of your personal account, its convenience, formats and types of broker reporting.

7. Versions, types and technologies of trading terminals and applications, as well as their cost. As a rule, brokers have trading terminals in versions on brokers' websites via Internet browsers, personal computers, mobile devices. Paid and free. They are usually divided into popular (Metatrader, CQG, and others) and proprietary (TWS, TigerTrade, LightSpeed, and others)

Below are the main questions, the answers to which will help you choose the broker that best suits your needs.

Algorithm for choosing a foreign stock broker

Algorithm for choosing a foreign stock broker

Every investor needs to answer the following questions - this will give you an understanding of what your personal priorities are when choosing a broker:

1. Decide on the purposes of using a foreign account? For example, diversification of the risk of the country of residence, in other words, storing assets in another country or the convenience of services for trading or the reliability of the foreign infrastructure of property rights to investment assets.

2. Broker reliability. How critical is this factor for you? Reliability, guarantees, brand, asset insurance, experience in the market - these are all relative concepts. Even large banks go bankrupt, and offshore brokers can work for decades. But at least a license, five years of experience in the market, regulation and supervision of the broker should be there.

3. Decide which jurisdiction of a foreign broker suits you? An offshore jurisdiction implies lower tax and regulatory costs, as well as verification of the origin of the investor's funds. On the contrary, a large international broker will ask many questions about you and your funds, bureaucratize processes and formalities.

4. Decide what amounts you will invest? If we are talking about hundreds of dollars, then we need to take into account the minimum asset lots, commissions depending on the volume and minimum deposit amounts with brokers. For large and well-known international brokers, clients with amounts up to $ 10,000 are not interesting.

5. Decide how often you will make purchase/sale transactions of financial instruments? If you are inclined to speculative and frequent transactions, then it is worth studying the brokers' tariffs specifically for traders and favorable conditions for trading contracts on the Futures markets. For long-term and fundamental investors, it is worth paying attention to tariffs with minimal monthly write-offs and direct access to exchanges so that the property rights to securities are recorded for you and securely stored in the depository records.

6. Decide what types of financial instruments you will work with? Stocks, bonds, contracts, ETFs, currencies. Not all brokers provide direct access to exchanges or specific types of assets, and do not register the property rights to company securities for you personally. Basically, those brokers who register on exchanges, as a rule, work with clients with amounts from $ 10,000. However, it is not convenient for companies and exchanges to regularly record the daily transfers of property rights of millions of small exchange speculators, so they shift this work to brokers or set high tariffs. As a result, many brokers actually execute transactions with clients within themselves, without sending transactions to the exchange. This is neither good nor bad. If the broker is reliable, then for the client, it is much more convenient and cheaper, otherwise small clients of brokers would have to pay many times larger commissions.

7. Decide on the broker's services and products that you would like to use? The product line, their profitability, convenience and quality are what brokers compete with each other for clients' money. The same product or service can vary greatly between two brokers in terms of quality, commissions and potential profitability.

8. Decide whether you will trade with borrowed funds? Terms and fees of margin trading, risk rates, carrying over positions to the next day, playing for a fall (short), risk management parameters - all this is for experienced investors and traders, but the potential profitability is significantly higher than trading only with your own funds.

9. Decide whether you will open short positions and take securities from the broker for short sales (short)? Here you also need to study in the broker's working conditions a number of features related to credit rates, the broker's ability to take your securities for other short sellers, and most importantly, the liquidity of the broker's assets.

10. Determine how important is broker support for you? Brokers have many clients, all of whom have their own questions that require highly qualified customer support staff, prompt response, regular and complete notifications about changes in working conditions, 24/7 availability, multilingualism, and the level of training of technical consultants on the operation of services and applications.

Based on your personal needs, you can evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of each broker and roughly understand which one is most suitable for you.

We recommend using our comparison table of foreign brokers.

Brokers' investment products

The most popular services for investors and traders among broker clients are:

  • Trading on exchanges and Margin trading
  • Investment Securities, Funds, ETF
  • Global Futures, Options, CFD
  • Robotrading and algotrading, high-frequency trading
  • Invest planning, financial adviser
  • Robo-advisors
  • Asset management
  • Copy trading, autofollowing
  • Capital protected structured products
  • Pre-IPO, OTC, SPAC)
  • Cryptocurrency trading

How do we compare brokers?

To obtain an assessment and rating, the main parameters are compared: reliability, favorable commissions, customer support, access to markets, trading terminals and services.

Products and services for investors and traders are considered separately. This is necessary for an accurate and high-quality choice of the best broker.

What parameters, products, services are taken into account?

General parameters

  • Broker Reliability
  • Application
  • General Fees
  • Customer Support
  • Markets

Investors:

  • Copytrading
  • Individual Investment Products
  • Structured Products
  • Robo-Advisors
  • IPO, pre-IPO
  • World ETF

Traders:

  • Trading terminals
  • Margin loans
  • Algo trading / High-frequency trading
  • Access to exchanges
  • Options, futures
  • Commissions for traders